Paige Carson never expected that both a handsome sheriff and a charismatic newcomer would be vying for her affections. The choice isn't an easy one, as she's now responsible for raising her orphaned goddaughter, Jess.
Sheriff Sam Wallace didn't lose at love. He got kicked to the curb. Hopeful that courting the feisty Paige will end differently, he can't help but feel suspicious about his romantic rival. Is Ben Hampshire the man he seems—or is Sam's jealousy clouding his perspective?
Sam's determined to win Paige's and Jess's love, but he also has to keep Providence Island safe. More than just Sam's heart is at risk if he fails to find the killer who walks the streets of PI—a killer with more than one agenda.